PSAPs vs OTC hearing aids: why cheap 'amplifiers' aren't the same

Search "hearing aid" and you will find two very different products at two very different prices. One is a regulated hearing aid. The other is usually a personal sound amplification product, or PSAP.

What a PSAP is

A PSAP makes everything louder. It is not regulated as a hearing aid, has no FDA device listing, and is often sold on volume alone — one setting, no hearing check, no fitting to your ears' needs.

What an OTC hearing aid is

Since October 2022 the FDA has a category for over-the-counter hearing aids: real hearing aids, for adults 18+ with perceived mild to moderate hearing loss, sold without a prescription. They are regulated medical devices with FDA-required warnings and labeling. Self-fitting ones, like Medlora's, also need FDA 510(k) clearance.

Medlora's model JH-DW3F is listed under 510(k) K221052, cleared by the FDA on September 25, 2023.

The differences that matter

  • Fitting: a PSAP amplifies; an OTC aid runs a hearing check per ear and saves settings to the device.
  • Programs: Medlora has 4 (Normal, Restaurant, Outdoor, Music); cheap amplifiers typically have one.
  • Streaming: OTC aids with Bluetooth 5.0 take calls and music; most PSAPs do not.
  • Regulation: OTC aids carry FDA-required warnings and labeling; PSAPs do not.

So is a PSAP ever enough?

If you only need a bit more volume for the TV, maybe. If you struggle with speech in noise, groups or calls, an actual hearing aid is the right category.

See the Medlora OTC hearing aids

Holiday season price

Found this guide useful?

Get our next guides by email, plus one reminder before the $399 holiday price ends on December 31.

Consumer Health Data Privacy Policy · Unsubscribe any time.